Our Gemara on Amud Aleph describes Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi as a unique combination of Torah knowledge and greatness. While the exact definition of greatness is not fully outlined, it appears to encompass attributes such as wealth, status, prestige, and wisdom.

One manifestation of this combination is evident in the special relationship between Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi and a Roman official named Antoninus. The Gemara in Avodah Zara (10b) documents their longstanding association characterized by Torah study, friendship, and intellectual exchange. Tosafos (ibid) even recounts traditions in which Antoninus' parents protected the newborn Rabbi Yehuda. In a situation where Rabbi Yehuda's parents were accused of violating Roman law by circumcising their child, Antoninus' parents allowed them to substitute their own child for Rabbi Yehuda, providing "proof" that the latter remained uncircumcised. Furthermore, according to the same source, there is a tradition suggesting that Antoninus converted to Judaism.

The identity of this historical figure, Antoninus, remains uncertain. It is challenging to ascertain his specific identity as Antoninus could have been a generic name used for various Roman leaders and officials, similar to Pharaoh. One plausible possibility is that Antoninus refers to the renowned stoic philosopher and general, Marcus Aurelius. Historical records indicate that Marcus Aurelius was born in 121 CE, while Rabbi Yehuda was born in 135 CE.

Although the timeline does not align perfectly with the tradition that both figures were infants at the time, we must recognize that the Gemara's precision in historical matters, particularly aggadah, is often less pronounced. The primary objective is to impart moral lessons rather than provide a historical account, given the absence of scientific historiography in those times. It is plausible that the substitute baby offered as evidence was a sibling or cousin of Marcus Aurelius. (For more on the historical accuracy of aggadah, and the three contradictory historical aggados about Rabbi Akiva, please refer to the article "History or His-story: Nedarim - Psychology of the Daf Yomi" by Simcha Feuerman, available at https://nefesh.org/SimchaFeuerman/history-or-his-story-nedarim--psychology-of-the-daf-yomi.html.)

Regardless, if we were to consider the possibility of Marcus Aurelius being Antoninus, it would be significant because he authored a book of private meditations that has been preserved to this day. Reading his meditations, one can recognize his profound philosophical wisdom. Furthermore, if some of his ideas were influenced through his association with Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi, they might even represent hidden sparks of Torah wisdom. Here are a few noteworthy quotes from Marcus Aurelius' meditations:

  1. "You don't have to turn this into something. It doesn't have to upset you."
  2. "Think of yourself as dead. You have lived your life. Now take what's left and live it properly."
  3. "Because most of what we say and do is not essential. Ask yourself at every moment, 'Is this necessary?'"
  4. "The impediment to action advances action. What stands in the way becomes the way."
  5. "Waste no more time arguing what a good man should be. Be one."
  6. "It's a disgrace in this life when the soul surrenders first while the body refuses to."
  7. "Your mind will take the shape of what you frequently hold in thought, for the human spirit is colored by such impressions."
  8. "Take a good hard look at people's ruling principle, especially of the wise, what they run away from & what they seek out."
  9. "Accept the things to which fate binds you and love the people with whom fate brings you together, but do so with all your heart."
  10. "Dig deep within yourself, for there is a fountain of goodness ever ready to flow if you will keep digging."

Translations Courtesy of Sefaria, except when, sometimes, I disagree with the translation cool

Do you like what you see? Please subscribe and also forward any articles you enjoy to your friends, (enemies too, why not?)