Our Gemara on Amud Beis delves into the matter of payment and the varying forms it can take depending on the nature and circumstances of the obligation. It teaches us that someone who causes damage and is required to pay from their land assets must pay from the best of their land. However, a debtor who utilizes land may use land of medium quality.

In a metaphorical and spiritual sense, mystics discuss how one should perceive sin and its consequences: Is it payment for damages or payment for debts?

For instance, the Chida (Nitzavim 2) applies this concept to explain the following verse (Devarim 29:18):

"When such a person hears the words of this curse, he may fancy himself immune, thinking, 'I shall be safe, though I follow my own willful heart'—thus adding drunkenness to thirst."

The Chida wonders how someone could rationalize that they will not be punished for their sinful behavior and that the admonitory curses will not be fulfilled. While I personally do not find this to be a profound question (as the saying goes, "Denial ain't just a river in Egypt"), the Chida considers this line of reasoning preposterous. Consequently, he proposes a deeper understanding regarding the mindset of the sinner:

The sinner believes that sins and their resulting punishments are comparable to debts, implying that payment will not be extracted from the highest quality land, but only from the middling quality. In this case, it means that the sinner will not suffer themselves, but rather their family members or possessions. However, God's response is that sins are not merely debts, but they are, in fact, damages (ניזקין), and the payment will be extracted from the highest quality real estate—the person themselves.

Continuing along this line of reasoning, let me add another dimension. It is typical of sinners to view their sins and punishment as transactional. Their relationship with God is reduced to a mere business transaction. Perhaps they believe that if they perform a mitzvah, they will receive a reward as payment, and if they choose to sin, they will pay the price of punishment, akin to a debtor repaying a loan. However, this way of thinking is distorted. Punishment is not God "paying you back"; rather, it is the unfortunate consequence of the damage inflicted upon one's own soul through their actions.

In his introduction to Perek Chelek, the Rambam explains that both reward and punishment are simplistic explanations provided to the unsophisticated, similar to how we give lollipops or spankings to little children. The truth of the matter is that the consequences of sin are far greater than the fires of hell, and the reward for mitzvot is far greater than any imaginable physical bliss. These experiences involve the attachment or detachment of the soul to God, which can be agonizing or blissful in ways that we cannot comprehend in the physical world. Rav Chaim Volozhin goes further (Nefesh HaChayyim 1:12) by stating that we shape our own heaven and hell moment by moment, as our sins either draw us closer to or distance us from God. Although we may not sense it in the physical world, this process is ongoing, and we will only fully realize it in what we refer to as the world to come. In reality, it is happening right now.

Rav Chaim Volozhin (Nefesh HaChayyim, near the beginning of Gate One) offers a unique perspective on being made in the image of God. Humans, to some extent, share a similarity with God in that their actions have a profound effect on the entire creation. Whatever humans do carries significant implications for all the universes.

The sages expressed this idea in Eikha Rabba (1:33, on verse 1:6): "Rabbi Azarya said in the name of Rabbi Yehuda, the son of Rabbi Seemon: 'When Israel performs God's will, the Almighty's power increases,' as it is written (Tehillim 60:14): 'Through Elokim we will make valor.' And when Israel does not perform God's will, it is as if they weaken the great power of heaven, as it is written (Devarim 32:18): 'Rock, your children weaken You.'"

The simple interpretation of the verse צ֥וּר יְלָדְךָ֖ תֶּ֑שִׁי (tzur yeladecha teshi) is "You forgot the one who formed you," but the derash (homiletic interpretation) suggests that it means "you weakened God's ability to have an impact in this world." The point is that we are made in the image of God, and our actions have cosmic implications.

Therefore, it is characteristic of sinners to be shortsighted and perceive their sins or rewards as mere transactions. However, in reality, they are not mere transactions. Each sin inflicts catastrophic spiritual damage, while every mitzvah creates unimaginable spiritual attachments and reverberations throughout creation. Thus, a sinner is not merely a debtor, but rather a mazik, a vandal inflicting damage.

In summary, our Gemara explores the concept of payment and its relation to obligations. Metaphorically, mystics contemplate the nature of sin and punishment, whether they are payments for damages or debts. The Chida suggests that sinners may falsely believe their punishment will be limited to secondary aspects of their lives, failing to realize that sins cause damage to their own souls. The Rambam and Rav Chaim Volozhin further elaborate on the profound consequences of sin and the spiritual impact of actions, emphasizing that reward and punishment go beyond simplistic explanations. Our actions have cosmic implications, shaping our connection to God and affecting the entire creation. Therefore, it is essential to understand that sin is not a mere transaction but a destructive force, while the fulfillment of mitzvos creates powerful spiritual attachments.

Translations Courtesy of Sefaria, except when, sometimes, I disagree with the translation

Do you like what you see? Please subscribe and also forward any articles you enjoy to your friends, (enemies too, why not?)